The reports are in, and while Black Friday 2025 saw a record number of shoppers, the sales figures tell a more complex story. Despite crowded stores and heavy foot traffic, preliminary data reveals a disconnect between the number of people shopping and the amount they actually spent.

Circana's Chief Retail Advisor, Marshal Cohen, breaks down the early results and what they signal for the remainder of the holiday retail season. While the enthusiasm for deals was high, the final numbers suggest consumers are being more selective with their purchases.

Watch the full video below for Marshal's quick-hit analysis.

A Closer Look at the Black Friday Numbers

At first glance, the bustling stores suggested a banner year. However, the initial data for the week ending November 29 shows a different reality. Retail sales dollars were down 2.7%, and the number of units sold fell by 5%. This indicates that even though consumers were out in full force, their baskets weren't as full as in previous years.

This trend highlights a cautious consumer mindset. Shoppers are participating in sales events, but they are prioritizing value and making more deliberate choices. The decline in units sold suggests that many are buying fewer items, a key factor that could impact the overall success of the holiday season for retailers.

The Bright Spots: What Consumers Were Buying

While overall sales saw a dip, several categories performed exceptionally well, capturing the attention and dollars of holiday shoppers.

• Toys and Hobbies: The toy sector had strong performers with trading cards and construction sets leading the way. These items continue to be popular gifts for a wide range of age groups.

• Beauty on the Rise: In the beauty business, fragrance and hair products were hot items. Consumers continue to invest in self-care and personal luxury, making this a resilient category.

• Tech Triumphs: Technology remains a holiday staple. This year, shoppers focused on practical and personal tech, with tablets, headphones, and fitness trackers topping the list.

• Seasonal Boost: The arrival of colder weather provided a timely lift for apparel, footwear, and accessories. Promoted items in these categories saw a surge as consumers refreshed their winter wardrobes.

• 
  

Holiday Forecast: Fewer Gifts Under the Tree?

Based on these early results, the holiday season is shaping up to be flat in terms of dollar sales. With unit sales declining, this forecast points toward a holiday with potentially fewer gifts under the tree for many families.

Retailers will need to work hard in the coming weeks to make up lost ground. Promotions, targeted offers, and an emphasis on value will be crucial for convincing discerning consumers to spend. The performance of key categories shows that shoppers are willing to buy, but they are looking for the right products at the right price.